As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Soft and fluffy homemade strawberry cake made with fresh strawberries and topped with a creamy strawberry buttercream.
Middle of July already?? How? HOW? That can only mean one thing… We are more than halfway through our cake of the month adventure. How are we doing? Have you made any yet?
I know last month’s cake was a big hit and I saw manyyyy beautifully swirly pictures on IG! Thank you for tagging me!
Let’s see here… In past Cakes of The Month, we’ve made:
- yellow layer cake with chocolate buttercream
- dark chocolate cake with peanut butter frosting
- white layer cake with whipped cream buttercream
- banana crumb snack cake
- ice cream sheet cake
- red, white, & blue swirl bundt cake
Today, we’re visiting a cake that I’ve had in my back pocket for many years. I used to make this fresh strawberry cake often for custom cake customers, and it was wildly popular in the summer months.
The reason I’m bringing it to the blog today is because it showcases one of the best fruits summer has to offer: fresh strawberries.
NO GELATIN, JUST REAL STRAWBERRIES
Back in the day, when I developed this recipe, I took to Google and Pinterest to find a homemade strawberry cake that was made with actual fruit. Can you believe it?
Have you ever tried to search for a fresh strawberry cake recipe from scratch? Or a strawberry cake recipe without gelatin? I found a lot of recipes were made with strawberry jelly, jam, or even Jell-O, but that’s not at all what I was looking for.
I wanted soft, fluffy cake dotted with actual bits of strawberries, and a strawberry cake without gelatin. I found strawberry cupcakes from Brown Eyed Baker that I figured I could turn into a cake, and after a few tries, I settled on this lovely little number I’m sharing with you today.
HOW TO MAKE FRESH STRAWBERRY CAKE
The ingredients in this fabulous strawberry layer cake are nothing you haven’t seen already in cake. Nothing special, nothing fancy, and no artificial flavors.
You’ll be getting 100% of the strawberry flavor in this cake from actual, juicy strawberries. 2 cups of them! That’s about 16 large strawberries. So much flavor!
The cake itself lends to a soft and fluffy texture. You might think this cake should be dense and heavy, but it is absolutely not. It’s basically like eating a strawberry cloud. Can you dig it?
The only thing that makes this easy strawberry cake better is the absolutely creamy dreamy strawberry buttercream that gets slathered all over every inch of it. Ohhh, it is SO GOOD.
THE SECRET TO STRAWBERRY BUTTERCREAM
I spent a whole lot of time trying to make strawberry frosting in my past cake baker life, and I always failed miserably. I never got the right ratio of strawberries to sugar and butter in order to get great flavor and also avoid making a shloopy, drippy mess.
I even tried using strawberry puree, but still didn’t love the result.
Like I said, failed miserably. It wasn’t until I had a lightbulb moment and wondered if freeze-dried strawberries might do the trick. Spoiler alert: they were perfect.
We can get freeze-dried strawberries in the dried fruit section of our grocery store, so if you aren’t sure yours carries them, check that section carefully! I was surprised to find them there.
You’ll need to blend up approximately 1 cup of the freeze dried strawberries, winding up with about 1/2 cup of strawberry powder.
That will go directly into your basic buttercream (the same recipe I use here) and it will lend the most wonderful strawberry flavor while also keeping the integrity of your sturdy buttercream intact.
Win win, people!
The second you have a taste of this homemade strawberry cake with strawberry buttercream, you’ll wonder where this cake has been all of your summer so far.
It is the perfect way to use up that beautiful produce that is just calling your name every time you’re in the grocery store, and you won’t regret the time it takes to hull and chop all those strawberries. Totally worth the work.
This is, hands down, the best strawberry cake recipe I have ever had. Ever.
And if you want to turn it into a bundt cake, here’s my recipe for strawberry bundt cake with strawberry ganache!
We dined on this sweet and slightly tart cake all 4th of July weekend, and it was a huge hit everywhere it went, which was, surprisingly, a few people’s houses.
In fact (!!!!), our son has proved not to love cake so much (I’m a little heart broken), but he couldn’t get enough of this stuff. Perhaps it was all the fruitiness, who knows, but you definitely need this cake in your life this summer.
Besides, just look at those gorgeous strawberry studs and the color of that buttercream! Who can resist that?
Fresh Strawberry Cake with Strawberry Buttercream
Ingredients
STRAWBERRY CAKE
- 3 and 1/4 cups (390g) all-purpose flour
- 4 teaspoons baking powder
- 1 teaspoon salt
- 1 cup (224g) unsalted butter softened to room temperature
- 2 cups (400g) granulated sugar
- 1 and 1/2 teaspoons vanilla extract
- 3 large eggs
- 1 large egg white
- 1 cup (240g) milk any
- 2 cups finely chopped strawberries approximately 16 large strawberries
STRAWBERRY BUTTERCREAM
- 1 cup (10-12g) freeze-dried strawberries
- 1 cup (224g) unsalted butter softened to room temperature
- 4 to 5 cups (480-600g) powdered sugar
- 1/4 to 1/3 cup (60-80g) milk or cream
- 2 teaspoons vanilla extract
- salt to taste
Instructions
STRAWBERRY CAKE
- Place oven rack on the middle setting and preheat the oven to 350ºF (177ºC). Grease and flour (or use homemade cake release) two 8" or 9" round cake pans.
- In a medium size bowl, whisk together the flour, baking powder, and salt. Set aside.
- In a large bowl with a handheld mixer, or the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, cream the butter, sugar, and vanilla until pale (approximately 3 minutes). Add the eggs and egg white one at a time, allowing each to incorporate before adding the next one and scraping the. Scrape down the sides of the bowl when necessary.
- Reduce the mixer speed to low and add the flour mixture in 2 parts, alternating with the milk. Gently fold in strawberries by hand.
- Divide batter evenly between the two prepared cake pans. Bake cakes for about 40-44 minutes or until a toothpick inserted in the center comes out clean and the tops are lightly browned. Remove from oven and allow cakes to cool completely on a wire rack before assembling.
STRAWBERRY BUTTERCREAM
- Using a blender or food processor, process the freeze-dried strawberries into a fine powder. Set aside.
- In a large bowl with a handheld mixer, or a stand mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, beat the butter on medium speed until creamy, about 2 minutes.
- With the mixer on low, add in the powdered sugar, vanilla, and milk or cream. Add the strawberry powder, increase mixer speed to medium, and beat until completely smooth, about 3 minutes. If frosting is too stiff, add more milk. If it is too thin, add more powdered sugar. Add salt to taste.
ASSEMBLE THE CAKE
- Trim cooled cake layers to create a flat surface. You can do this with a large serrated knife or a cake leveler. Place one layer on a plate or cake stand and cover the top with strawberry buttercream frosting. Spread evenly with an offset spatula.
- Place second layer on top, cut surface down. For a sturdier cake, refrigerate at this point for about 10 minutes. When cake is slightly chilled, remove from refrigerator and spread more frosting on the top and around the sides. Serve. Leftovers stay fresh, covered tightly, at room temperature up to 5 days and in the refrigerator up to 1 week.
- Make ahead: prepare cakes and frosting up to 1 day in advance. Cover cakes tightly and keep at room temperature or in the refrigerator until ready to assemble. Refrigerate prepared frosting in an airtight container until ready to use. Unfrosted cake layers may be frozen, wrapped tightly, up to 2 months. Thaw overnight in the refrigerator before assembling. Frosted cake can be frozen, wrapped tightly, up to 2 months. Thaw overnight in the refrigerator and bring to room temperature before serving.
Megan - The Emotional Baker says
I love this cake of the month series! I wish I had more opportunities to make layer cakes. Next time I make one, it will have to be strawberry. I love that you used fresh and freeze dried strawberries!
Andrea says
Made this strawberry cake for my son’s birthday. Turned out denser than most cakes. The flavor was good.
I didn’t use freeze dried strawberries. I dehydrated fresh ripe strawberries and. Ground them in a small food Processor. Flavor was wonderful, color pretty pink
Courtney says
I have been trying to figure our what to make for my birthday cake next month (yes I am one of those people). I think this might be at the top of the list, I love all the real strawberries in the batter and that buttercream, OMG! The cake looks perfect and fluffy. Thanks for posting your beloved recipe and I will report back if I make it.
Courtney says
Oh, one more thing, what is the bake time on this? I think it was supposed to be step 3 but it is not there.
Lynn says
Hi Courtney! SO sorry, that was a complete oversight on my part. I didn’t even type out the recipe– I just left my shorthand notes in there! It’s now fixed and all the pertinent information is there 🙂 thanks for pointing that out for me!
Traci says
Was there suppose to be baking soda in this recipe? I did alter Slightly as I puréed the strawberries. It was delicious but quite dense so I was unsure if there was suppose to be baking soda and baking powder.
Lynn says
Nope, no baking soda. Pureeing the strawberries will give you more liquid and weigh down the batter. It’s not a “light” cake, but it’s certainly not dense.
Leah | Grain Changer says
YES for REAL strawberries! Girl, this looks incredible. And SO SMART to use freeze dried strawberries for the buttercream. I’ve always had a ton of trouble using juicy berries to work in a buttercream, and this is just pure genius. YUM!
Lynn says
Exactly– and it’s a darn shame because fruity buttercream is AMAZEEEEBALLS!!
Karen Kennedy says
I used an immersion blender to liquefy a couple of ripe strawberries. I added a couple of tablespoons of the liquid to the butter cream and reduced the volume of cream. It was excellent. The icing had a lovely strawberry flavour and was a gorgeous shade of pink. I made this cake for a 65th birthday party it was a big hit. Thanks for the recipe!
Lynn says
Thanks for the feedback, Karen! Glad you enjoyed it!
Amy says
Lynn! This is just perfect! Strawberries are everywhere in our supermarkets at the moment and they are so sweet and juicy. I’ve been searching for the best fresh strawberry cake for a long time, and now you’ve created it! I can’t wait to try this out ASAP to make the most of our winter strawberry haul! So beautiful!
Lynn says
Thanks, friend! Strawberries are one of the best fruits you can put in a dessert, I think!
Elizabeth Clark says
Do you mean 4 sticks of butter in the cake mix? It says 1 cup then 2 sticks (which I know is the equivalent of one cu
Lynn says
It should say “1 cup (2 sticks),” but I just switched over to a new site/new formatting, so I’m still working through fixing the formatting issues!
Ericka says
Could this be made into cupcakes? If so, do you have an idea how many?
Lynn says
Hey, Ericka! Absolutely. It will make about 32 cupcakes, bake time is 25-30 minutes. Enjoy!
Ericka says
Thank you! If I was wanting to half this recipe, what would be your flour and egg suggestion? Thanks!
Lynn says
For flour: 1 and 1/2 cups + 2 Tablespoons, and for the eggs: I would drop down to one large egg and keep the whole large egg white.
Lissa says
I think I love you! ❤️
But seriously, my little girl loves strawberries (doesn’t care for chocolate) so this is her birthday cake. She is one happy 10 year old!
Lynn says
Hahaha, well thanks, Lissa! I’m so glad you enjoyed the cake! PS my birthday was yesterday (9/26) so are your daughter and I birthday buddies? Happy birthday to her, whenever it is!
Stephanie DeWitt says
Just made this and cannot wait to eat it!!! Thanks so much for the fresh recipie!
Lynn says
I hope you enjoyed it, Stephanie!
Barbara First says
I need to make this in a 9×13 pan. Would the temp. and time be the same?
Lynn says
Temperature would be the same, but you’ll want to decrease the baking time. I would try starting with something like 25 minutes and checking from there.
Lisa says
Can frozen strawberries work?
Lynn says
Yes, they can. Try to get as much moisture out of them if you can, if you’re going to thaw them. I would probably use them frozen, but you’ll need to chop them up first.
Michelle Edwards says
Delicious! Thank you for this from scratch Strawberry cake recipe. I made this yesterday to bring to work today for a friends birthday. Everyone loved it. I found the freeze dried strawberries at Whole Foods. I followed the recipe as written and it was perfect! So glad I found your website/blog!
Lynn says
So glad you and your friends loved it! Thanks for letting me know 🙂
Greg says
This looks amazing. Just curious why no cake flour
Lynn says
Cake flour isn’t always necessary in cake. Unless you’re looking for a super soft and delicate crumb, you can get away with just all purpose. Because this cake is packed with real strawberries, we aren’t in the market for a soft crumb here. Something like my white cake (https://freshaprilflours.com/2017/03/29/white-layer-cake-with-whipped-cream-buttercream/) uses all purpose + cornstarch which is equivalent to cake flour.
Amanda says
Can you use cake flour? How many cups is it the same ratio ?
Lynn says
It’s 1 cup + 2 Tablespoons of cake flour for every cup of all purpose flour.
Amanda says
It looks and sounds amazing! I’m just curious, could I substitute the fresh strawberries for freeze-dried in the cake batter? If so, how much?
Lynn says
Hi, Amanda! You probably could, though I’d be concerned you’d be missing out on a mega moisture factor. If you try it, let me know! I would try about a cup.
Kelly Saine says
Would this strawberry cake pair well with cream cheese frosting in your opinion? My mother in law has requested a strawberry cake, but with cream cheese frosting. Thanks in advance for your help!
Lynn says
Hey, Kelly! That sounds fabulous. If you don’t have a cream cheese frosting recipe, I have one here. You can always keep the addition of the strawberry powder from this recipe in order to make strawberry cream cheese frosting, but of course, that’s not totally necessary, just a suggestion! Let me know how it works out 🙂
Kelly Saine says
Hi! I know this is a super late reply, but my mother in law LOVED your cake! I ended up using your cream cheese frosting recipe as well and I added the freeze dried strawberries to make it strawberry cream cheese frosting. It was amazing! I loved the cake so much that I’m making it for my birthday tomorrow! Thank you for your help and my new go to birthday cake!
Lynn says
Oh, I love this report! Thanks for letting me know, Kelly! What a delish combo. I hope you have a wonderful birthday 🙂
Anne Walzak says
Hi, for the icing do I chop up the frozen strawberries or due I thaw them…I’m just a little confused on that part.
Lynn says
Hi, Anne– you’ll be using freeze-dried strawberries for the frosting.
Carolyn Lee says
I used frozen strawberries to make the buttercream yesterday. ~3/4 cup in a single serve blender jar on a low setting, just until they were chopped down (maybe 10-15 seconds). I used a little less than 1/4 cup milk, and I also chilled it a little before spreading it on the cake. It turned out great, and everybody loved it!
Lynn says
So glad that worked for you, Carolyn! Thanks for sharing!
Sally says
Oh my goodness .. this was so good! I did one strawberry and one blueberry!!!
I actually substituted 1/2 the sugar in the cake with stevia and 1/4 the icing sugar was Swerve confectioners blend! It still did Great!
The strawberry was my favorite but the blueberry cake was so yummy!!
Lynn says
Thanks for sharing, Sally! And IG’ing it! And thanks for sharing your successful substitutions 🙂
Emma says
I followed the recipe and my cake cooked un even and tasted like cornbread
Lynn says
Hey, Emma! I’m not sure what went wrong, but it sounds like you may have used a wrong ingredient. Unless you used cornmeal instead of flour, there’s hardly a way for this to taste like cornbread, especially if you added strawberries. This is one of my most popular and positively reviewed recipes.
Betsy says
Did you use freeze dried blueberries for the frosting and fresh blueberries for the cake? Doing a baby shower and the mom to be isn’t finding out the sex of the baby, so I want one pink and one blue dessert!!
Gerri says
Was just ok. I found it to be a little dry.
Luthien says
I just made these for my niece’s first birthday and they came out great! I used a 1:1 gluten free flour blend, and was a little bit worried about how thick the batter was, but after they cooked with the moisture from the strawberries it was perfect. Thank you!
Lynn says
So glad you enjoyed the recipe!
Sue Day says
Can you email me the fresh Strawberry Cake recipe? It looks amazing!
Lynn says
Hi, Sue! The recipe is right there on the page. You actually have to scroll past it to comment on the blog. There’s a “print” button so you can print it right from your screen. Thanks!
Marilyn Sirkis says
Tried this Strawberry cake recipe for the first time. Cake was very crumbly which made it hard to ice. Any suggestions?
Lynn says
Hey, Marilyn. Cake is fairly crumbly on the outsides normally. I always do a crumb coat to lock in the crumbs and make it easier to ice. Unless you feel the inside was also crumbly, I don’t think anything went wrong.
Rasanjali says
I made this cake for one of my customers…. and it came out absolutely perfect!!! Love the texture and the taste is spot on!! I never liked using extracts and Jello for cakes with fruits and this definitely the winner for me. Thank you so much for sharing this with us.
Lynn says
Thanks so much! I’m so glad you enjoyed it 🙂
Lea says
Just made this cake for my son’s 5th birthday, and it was amazing! Everyone loved it. So moist and tasty, and such a beautiful natural color. He requested a strawberry cake, and I feel so lucky I stumbled upon your recipe when looking for one with real fruit! I doubled it and made a two-layer cake and 24 cupcakes.
Lynn says
This warms my heart, Lea! Thanks so much for finding me and trusting my recipe. I’m so glad everyone enjoyed it.
Mary DeGuzman says
Lynn, I made this cake tonight and it was delicious! I didn’t have freeze dried strawberries, so I just used the rest of the fresh ones I chopped up for the buttercream. I squeezed as much liquid as I could out of them and it worked out just fine. This recipe is going to be saved! Thank you!
Lynn says
Great idea, Mary! So glad you enjoyed the cake.
Cynthia says
This looks amazing. I can’t seem to see where you add the strawberries to the cake mixture in the recipe. Could you please reply and let me know. Thanks!
Lynn says
Step 4.
Paula Crumpton says
Love this cake! Searching for a fresh strawberry cake, I chose this one and so glad I did. I did not have freeze dried strawberries so I sliced about 16 and put in my dehydrator for a few hours. Finely chopped them (not quite a cup) used 1/8 cup half and half and the icing was fantastic. Wonderful strawberry flavor! I did chill it before icing cake. Thanks for the recipe!
Lynn says
Awesome, Paula! Thanks for sharing!
Sarah says
I had a question. If I make this cake can I substitute milk for buttermilk? And should I add sour cream to make it even more moist or is that not a good idea? I love very very moist cake that is not dry at all. Also will I have to double the recipe for a 6in and 8in layer cake? Thank u 😊
Lynn says
Hey, Sarah! You can use buttermilk if you’d like, but it’s not necessary. This cake is a very moist cake. I wouldn’t add any sour cream. And if you want to do an 8″ and 6″ cake, you can get away with 1.5x the recipe 🙂
Casey says
I used two 8″ cake pans and it boiled over. I had to stop the baking, dump the pans half way through into a 9×13 pan to save the cake. I hope that it works out for my daughter’s birthday celebration.
Lynn says
I’m sorry to hear that, Casey. I’ve had many readers make this with no issue, and I myself have made this cake several times in two 8″ rounds without any problems. I’m glad you found a solution.
Cat says
I’m so glad I found this recipe! I’m with you, I kept looking for cake and buttercream recipes made with FRESH strawberry, but all I found were recipes that relied on jam or jello. I’ve been using an adapted recipe from Martha Stewart for cupcakes for YEARS, but it is pretty dense and I wanted a lighter recipe to make a layer cake for an upcoming bridal shower. This looks just perfect! I also have to freeze the layers due to time, so thank you for including that direction! I wanted to make a 3-layer cake though – do you think I can split this recipe and bake 3 layers? Or should I double the recipe and make 4 layers?
Lynn says
Hey, Cat! I hope you enjoy the recipe! It sounds like this is exactly what you’re looking for. If you want to make 3 layers, I suggest making 1.5x the recipe. You’ll get hung up on the eggs, so I would use 4 large eggs and 2 large egg whites. Let me know how it turns out!
Andrea says
Hi Lynn,
I came across your recipe on Pinterest and it couldn’t have been at a better time, as I am making my niece’s birthday cake for her party this weekend. It’s going to be a Care Bear themed fondant covered cake with either 2 or 4 layers. Probably just 2. But it’s a 12″ round cake. Can you help me with the ingredient amounts? I will probably just be using 2 of my 12″ pans, plus I wanted to make a few extra cupcakes. I start working on it tonight after I get home from work. Your thoughts would be greatly appreciated!
Lynn says
Hi, Andrea! I think I might have seen this a little too late– what did you wind up doing? I would probably just have doubled it to ensure I had enough for the cake and some extra cupcakes.
Andrea says
I actually haven’t made the cakes yet…this week hasn’t gone to plan at all so far. However I will get started in about an hour or so on them. I was actually thinking of doubling the recipe too. But when I did calculations on the amount of cups it still doesn’t seem like enough. So to play it safe I think I will make one batch at a time and fill my cake pans up until I’m satisfied and then bake them. That way I can at least make sure that they are fairly even layers.
Willie says
Some one post this to my FB page it looks so good I’m making one right now to take to church for our bake sale.
Stacy says
Just made the cake & this is no doubt the best strawberry cake recipe I’ve ever made. Made no changes whatsoever. Thank u!!!
Lynn says
Thank you, Stacy!
Elizabeth says
Made this for my sister-in-law’s birthday. Everyone loved it. I halved the powdered sugar in the buttercream frosting because we don’t eat really sweet things and it was still delicious (albeit thicker). Thanks!
Lynn says
So glad you and your people enjoyed it, Elizabeth!
Tara says
Hi! I just made this cake today and it smells and tastes divine. Weirdly, my cakes came out comply differently. I used one batch of batter and put them in the oven on the same shelf to bake at the same time. One came out perfectly risen and golden, and the other was slightly under baked (not as golden as the other) and sunken in the center. Any idea what could have happened here??
Lynn says
Interesting. It sounds like maybe some difference in the air flow or heating elements in your oven. I’m not sure what else would cause that!
Betsy says
This looks delicious! I would love to make these as cupcakes for an upcoming baby shower. Can you tell me if this frosting would work well to pipe flowers on the cupcakes? Or would the texture not be right for that? Thank you!
Lynn says
Hey, Betsy! This frosting is pipable.
Ella says
This is a fantastic cake and frosting recipe! Of course my grocery does not carry freeze-dried strawberries, so I had to do some quick thinking. I decided to make a strawberry coulis with fresh strawberries. I then pureed the coulis in the blender, strained out the seeds and added some of this thickened coulis to my frosting in place of the cream. Oh my goodness! So delicious and the most gorgeous shade of pink! Just another option for those that can’t find freeze-dried strawberries.
Lynn says
Thanks for sharing your adaptations, Ella! I’m so glad you loved the cake 🙂
Adrienne Adams says
This recipe was so great my husband was so upset with everyone leaving him a small piece that I had to make it again. Thank you so much
Lynn says
Hahaha, you’re such a great wife, Adrienne! I’m so glad you liked it!
Laura says
Looks great – want to make this two days ahead of time for a birthday but assemble on the day. Will the strawberries in the sponge be okay in an airtight container for two days?
Lynn says
Yes! Just keep them in the fridge.
D. Whitaker says
Hello, this looks fabulous!!! Question, cab this be made into a. 1/4 Sheet cake? I have to do a strawberry sheet cake for an event and wanted to know the best way to modify this into one!
Lynn says
Yes! This should fit nicely in a 9×13. I would suggest a bake time of 22ish minutes to start and then test it!
D. Whitaker says
Hi Lynn, do you think that I could use a Strawberry reduction in this cake? I baked it already and I really liked it! Just wanted to know if the strawberry reduction would help the strawberry flavor stronger and the color more pink without using food coloring.
Lynn says
I think that probably would work! I would try reducing the same amount of strawberries and just addung that in place of the strawberries. Let me know if you try it!
Dawn says
This was the most amazing cake ever! I made in 9×13 pan(lazy way). I used a different buttercream frosting as I did not have freeze dried. I have already shared with other family members as this is one that needs to be passed on! Thank you!
Lynn says
Thanks so much, Dawn!
Dini says
Hi, I want to use this strawberry buttercream under fondant. I don’t want to refrigerate the cake after putting fondant decorations. How long can the cake last in room temperature? The cake needs to be delivered on Saturday so do you think assembling on Friday and keeping it at room temperature is a good idea?
Lynn says
Yes— instructions for storing at room temp are in the recipe card!
deniz says
was going to make this cake for my sister in law. quick question i dont have a paddle for whipping the butter cream can i use a regular hand mixer to make the icing?
Lynn says
Yes— step 2 states hand mixer also works! Enjoy!
Mikey says
What would be the nutritional information for this cake, for example calories, sugar, fat etc per slice or 100grams?
Lynn says
Hi, Mikey– sorry, I don’t provide nutrition information for my recipes! It would all depend completely on exactly what ingredients you used. You’re welcome to use an app to calculate this and let me know what you find!
Elle says
Hello,
So I actually baked this twice! Well sorta… once correctly. Despite reading the recipe twice, I missed the part about adding the eggs and alternating with the milk so the texture was a bit off the first time. But I loved this cake. I just wanted to know if you had a page for frosting and cake baking tips in general. (I always find my inner layer too thin) and my frosting looking a bit uhhh rustic? 😬 if I’m being kind to myself hehe. Love your blog, your directions and your voice is so friendly!
Lynn says
Thanks for the comment, Elle! Unfortunately, I don’t have a resource for decorating a cake, but I would like to have one in the future.
Lauren says
How could I make these into cupcakes?
Lynn says
Hey, Lauren! This recipe will make about 24-30 cupcakes. Follow the recipe as-is, and bake for about 12-15 minutes. Enjoy!
Ellie says
This is my family’s favorite cake! So delicious! I will say to add the freeze dried strawberry powder gradually to taste, we ended up liking it best using a little less than directed. But this cake is a hit and the recipe is a keeper for sure:)
Lynn says
I love this! Thanks for sharing, Ellie.
Gunita Singh says
I made this cake last night. It was so tasty!!! I’m so glad I found this recipe. Thank you!!!!! So yummy!
Lynn says
You’re welcome! I’m so glad you enjoyed it 🙂
Crenee says
Finally, a strawberry cake without using gelatin. I have been searching for one for a couple years. The frosting recipe also helped me with making icing that wasn’t runny.
Lynn says
I’m so glad you enjoyed it!
Rochelle says
Hi! I’m really excited to try this! It’s 3:30am and it just went in the oven… lol
Anyways, I’m making this cake for a friends birthday but I’m making a cake with two 10” round bottoms, and one 8” sat on top. Three cake pans… the trick is I’m putting a bottle in the middle and I’m worried it will fall because everything I read says I need to support it! My batter was very thick so from my Research I am understanding it will be quite light. Is there a way to make the cake a bit more dense so it can hold another small layer cake on top? Should I just find dowels? Maybe the bottle (beer bottle laid flat in second layer lol) will support the top small cake?
Additionally, I’m wondering if you think the cake will be strong enough to stick things in the top without them falling over?
Sorry for these crazy questions. Thank you so much in advance!!
Lynn says
Hey, Rochelle– I never stack cakes without dowels. In fact, a lighter cake is better than a dense cake for stacking. And you should be able to put things in the top of the cake.
Tia says
I turned this into a bundt cake for Mother’s Day and it turned out amazing! I gave pieces away and everyone is asking when will another one be made. I topped it with a glaze but I’ll definitely try the buttercream icing next time! Thanks for sharing the recipe!! It was delicious!
Lynn says
Hey, Tia! I made it into a bundt cake too, haha! Here’s that recipe. I used a strawberry ganache that might interest you. Enjoy!
Jaime says
Hello I was wondering if this could be baked in one normal size cake pan ?
Lynn says
Like a sheet pan? Yes! This batter will fit in a 9″ x 13″ pan nicely. Add about 4-5 minutes to bake time.
Jaime says
Awesome thank you!
Steven Arnold says
This cake is amazing! Had some strawberries that I needed to use and decided to give this a shot. One of my new favorites!
I made a whipped cream frosting instead of the buttercream. Perfection!
Lynn says
I am so glad you enjoyed this cake!
Litza says
Just made this and it was AMAZING! I followed all the instructions but I didn’t have round cake pans so I used 9×13 inch pan, in which the batter almost came to the top. It almost overflowed while baking but didn’t thankfully. It took about 46-49 mins to cook doing it this way. It was a tiny bit dense but I’m sure it’s because there was too much batter in the pan. Regardless, the cake was ridiculously delicious! Next time I think I will half the recipe or keep it the same and make a 9×13 cake plus a few cupcakes. Thank you for the wonderful recipe. (After writing this review I just measured my pan and it’s actually 7.5 x 11.75 inches! And all these years I always thought it was 9×13! Thanks Pyrex! Ha ha. Anyways it still came out great. Can’t wait to try it again with the right sizes as I’m sure it will be even more delicious if that’s possible. Ha ha!).
Lynn says
HAHA! This just made me laugh out loud! I was going to say… This should definitely fit in a 9×13 nicely! So glad you liked it and yes, please let me know how next time goes in an ACTUAL 9×13 😉
Litza says
So I have made this (in correct size pans this time) 2 more times plus did them as cupcakes as well and all of them came out delicious! I have to say very happy to have my go to strawberry baking recipe! Thank you!
Amy says
This cake looks amazing. My nephew has requested a strawberry cake with chocolate frosting for his birthday. Have you ever tried this combination?
Lynn says
That is a great combo, Amy!
Megan says
This cake recipe is so delicious! I usually don’t care for homemade cakes that I’ve made, but this was phenomenal! So fluffy! We made it as a sheet cake for the 4th of July and it is amazing! We left the strawberries out of the frosting recipe because we wanted a red, white and blue cake, but would love to try the strawberry frosting sometime.
Lynn says
I love this! Thanks so much for your review, Megan.
Sierra says
Hi I don’t have an electric mixer, can I do this cake by hand?
Lynn says
You should be able to cream butter and sugar without a mixer, but you’ll need a bit of elbow grease! Hope this helps!
Jen says
fyi – 350 in F is 175 in C (I think you have a typo)
Lynn says
You’re not the first person to tell me this– but the formula I learned in high school and throughout earning my degree and in the workplace (a chem lab) give us 176.6, which rounds to 177. Can you tell me where 175 comes from??
Suzanne says
This looks so good! I love all the troubleshooting to get just the right flavors!
Lynn says
Thanks so much, Suzanne 🙂 I hope you’ll try it!
Vanessa says
Thanks for sharing! Does it keep long?
Lynn says
Storage instructions are in the recipe!
Dave says
Our family is expanding and our son’s future mother-in-law’s favorite cake is strawberry. Local berries were in season so that made life easier but what to do for frosting? How to showcase strawberries throughout without getting a weepy mess? Browsing the web, I came across your recipe. It ticked all the boxes I wanted so, what the heck, I used your whole offering. FANTASTIC!! Hands down the best strawberry cake I’ve ever had. No need to ever look for another recipe. The cake is spot on. And the frosting is brilliant. Thank you for sharing the recipe for a truly great cake. Well done!
Lynn says
Thank you so much for this review, Dave! It makes me so happy to hear this. Don’t miss the strawberry bundt cake, made with the same base recipe but with a strawberry ganache on top. Congratulations on the expansion of your family 🙂
Courtney says
Baking time suggestion for using three 6×2 inch pans?
Lynn says
Hey, Courtney! I’d start with 32-35 minutes and see where that gets you.
Sheryll says
Would the amount of batter overflow in two 6 inch pans?
Lynn says
For 6″ pans, I’d halve the recipe.
Aya Cruz says
Made the cake for my sister’s birthday, and it was a hit! Super yunmy! My mom’s birthday is coming up and wanted to use the cake recipe without the strawberry. Will it affect the cake or shall I substitute something else for the strawberries? Thank you!!
Lynn says
Hi, Aya! Thanks so much for your great feedback. I’m so glad you enjoyed the recipe. If you want to make this cake without the strawberries, I’m afraid it won’t work out as nicely as simply omitting them. I’d direct you to either my white layer cake or yellow layer cake. Enjoy!
Ronak Mehta says
Wow. It looks delicious. I love strawberry cakes. So, I will try to make it. Your recipe will help me. Thanks for sharing.
Sheryll says
I made this cake once and it was soooooo good!!!! Best strawberry cake I’ve had!
Does the cake freeze well? I plan to make a cake as well as cupcakes with this recipe and don’t want to do everything in one day.
Lynn says
Hey, Sheryll! Yes– freezes great. See step 3 labeled “make ahead.”
Sheryll says
If I wanted to make a 2 layer 6 inch cake as well as 12 cupcakes…will mutiplying the ingredients by 1.5 work?
Lynn says
For either of those options, halving the recipe is sufficient!
Sheryll says
So if I plan to do both a 6 inch cake and 12 cupcakes then just do one batch of your current recipe?
Bhuvanesh Manhas says
Hey! Looks amazing.
Can this be done without eggs? Please suggest the replacement with yoghurt.
Lynn says
Hi! I’ve never made this cake without eggs, so I can’t advise how to proceed. If you try it, let me know!