Piña Colada Bars
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Read the full disclosure here.
These non-alcoholic tropical coconut custard bars have chunks of pineapple and shredded coconut all on top of a crunchy graham cracker crust.
Long ago, back in 2014 when I started my website, I published these piña colada bars and they went BANANAS on Pinterest. Since then, I’ve had a pretty steady flow of visitors to this recipe, but have never been 100% on board with the final product after hearing reader reviews.
I love growing and learning more and expanding my baking skills, and since these bars’ debut, I have been itching to get to this recipe to make it better than ever.
Back in the spring when I made my coconut custard pie, I discovered that a coconut custard type filling is what these piña colada squares were missing. So I took to the kitchen, selected my best coconut ingredients, and made these bars exactly what I wanted them to be.
INGREDIENTS
There are two components to these piña colada bars: a crunchy graham cracker crust and a texture-filled coconuts and pineapple filling.
GRAHAM CRACKER CRUST
We’ve made this graham cracker crust many times before, and this time is no different. I use the same recipe for a graham cracker crust any time I need one, and all you’ll need for it are graham crackers, melted butter, and brown sugar.
So easy! And a wonderful complement to the filling.
PINEAPPLE COCONUT CUSTARD FILLING
The filling, which originally used sweetened condensed milk modeled after my Key lime pie bars, now uses coconut milk and granulated sugar in place of it.
A note on the coconut milk– you will need this at room temperature where it is often separated into fat and liquid. Take care opening your can, or, if it’s warm enough, you may be able to turn it into a complete liquid by shaking it before adding it to your other ingredients.
Other ingredients you’ll need for the filling: cream cheese, egg yolks, some vanilla extract, a little salt, and to bring all the true piña colada flavor, crushed pineapple and sweetened shredded coconut.
You might be wondering to yourself… Where is the rum?
Although there is no actual alcohol in these bars, you can most certainly add some rum extract to make these truly a cocktail dessert. See my notes at the bottom of the recipe for suggestions.
HOW TO MAKE PIÑA COLADA BARS
As per usual for graham cracker crusts, this part is really simple.
Gather the ingredients into a food processor and pulverize everything. Add the melted butter and the sugar and continue to combine.
You’ll press this mixture into the bottom of an 8″ square pan lined with parchment or foil (I prefer foil).
Then, you’ll bake this for about 8-10 minutes just so it can set up.
For the filling, you’ll start by creaming together the cream cheese and granulated sugar. To this, you’ll add two egg yolks, then the coconut milk and the vanilla extract.
Remember, your coconut milk may be separated, so take care when emptying the contents into your mixture.
Lastly, we’ll add some salt and then crushed pineapple and ⅔ cup of the sweetened shredded coconut.
Your crushed pineapple should be drained, but it does not need to be bone dry. Don’t worry about wringing out all of the moisture, but do be sure to press out as much as you can before taking it out of the can.
Once these ingredients are all well combined, pour it into the pre-baked graham cracker crust, then sprinkle the remaining ⅓ cup of sweetened shredded coconut on top.
You will bake these piña colada cheesecake bars for a long time– over 1 hour. Remember that this is a coconut custard based bar, so it will need longer to set than traditional bars made with cream cheese.
Once baked, they’ll need to cool completely before you refrigerate them to cut and serve them. This is crucial in letting the bars set the whole way.
For me, there is no such thing as too much coconut in my life, and these bars are jam-packed with it. It’s the perfect summery dessert and worth all the heat of turning on the oven.
The coconut sprinkled on top browns just a little bit, so the slight toasted coconut flavor in each bite meshes well with the sweetness of the bar.
My favorite part of the bar, though, is the caramelized edges that come from the baking of the pineapple juice. It makes the bars just the right amount of sticky and chewy that belong in a dessert.
To make things even more fun, I sometimes top my bars with a maraschino cherry, so it is essentially a chewy cocktail. Now that I’ve typed that, it sounds kind of gross, but I promise, these bars are a tropical dream.
If you like piña coladas, you must try this dessert.
And the best part? You can eat ALL of these bars and not have a hangover!
Ok, ok, please don’t do that… It would probably be not so great for your belly! Besides, these are too good not to share with fellow piña colada loving friends, so gather them ’round and get to baking!
If you like piña coladas, and want to try more desserts (did you sing that? I hope so!): piña colada coconut macaroons and piña colada granola.
Piña Colada Bars
Ingredients
CRUST
- 1 and ½ cups (150g) graham cracker crumbs 10 or 11 full sheets
- 5 Tablespoons (72g) unsalted butter melted
- ¼ cup (50g) firmly packed light brown sugar
FILLING
- 6 ounces (171g) full fat block cream cheese softened to room temperature
- ⅔ cup (134g) granulated sugar
- 2 large egg yolks
- 1-14 ounce can coconut milk full fat; room temperature1
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract2
- ¼ teaspoon salt
- 1-8 ounce can crushed pineapple drained3
- 1 cup (120g) sweetened shredded coconut divided
Instructions
- Preheat the oven to 350ºF (177ºC).
- Line an 8″ x 8″ or 9″ x 9″ baking pan with foil. Leave an overhang on the sides and spray with nonstick spray. Set aside.
CRUST
- Use a food processor or blender to process full graham crackers into a fine crumb.
- Turn the processor or blender off, add the butter and sugar, then pulse a few times until everything is blended well. Alternatively, you can add the graham cracker crumbs to a bowl and mix the butter and sugar in with a large spatula. Mixture will be coarse and sandy.
- Use your hands to press the mixture evenly into the bottom of the prepared pan. Once it is evenly spread into the dish, use your hands or the bottom of a flat measuring cup to make the crust tight and compact in the pan.
- Bake the crust for 8-10 minutes then remove from the oven and allow to cool while you prepare the filling.
FILLING
- In the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, or in a medium size bowl with a handheld mixer, beat the cream cheese and granulated sugar on high until smooth.
- Add the egg yolks one at a time, beating after each addition, and scraping down the sides as necessary. Add the coconut milk and vanilla extract and beat again until everything is combined.
- Fold in the crushed pineapple and ⅔ cup of the sweetened shredded coconut until evenly dispersed.
- Pour the filling into the pre-baked crust, sprinkle remaining shredded coconut on top, and bake for 70-75 minutes. Bars are done when the edges are set, the shredded coconut is lightly toasted, and the middle no longer jiggles. Allow bars to cool to room temperature in the pan on a wire rack. When bars are completely cool, chill in the refrigerator for at least 2 hours.
- When bars are completely chilled, lift out of the pan using foil overhang and cut into squares. Bars can be stored covered in the refrigerator up to 1 week. Bars freeze well, up to 2 months. Thaw in the refrigerator.
Notes
- Room temperature coconut milk: at room temperature, coconut milk can still be separated into fat and liquid. Take care opening your can, or, if it’s warm enough, you may be able to turn it into a complete liquid by shaking it before adding it to your other ingredients.
- Vanilla extract: if you want to add rum to this, I suggest replacing the vanilla extract with rum extract. You can also replace with coconut extract. If you want to use rum extract and coconut extract, you can use 1 teaspoon of each.
- Crushed pineapple: while the pineapple should be drained well, it does not have to be pressed or squeezed dry.
Nutrition Disclosure
All nutritional values are approximate and provided to the reader as a courtesy. Changing ingredients and/or quantities will alter the estimated nutritional calculations.
Yummy!!! I am not a cocktail girl either – give me a glass of wine or scotch any day over something fruity and complicatedly sweet. However, I do love sweet baked things, and these sound like the perfect incarnation of a cocktail baked good to me!
Also, I might be a bit late to the party but I love, love, love the new website design!!!!
Thank you so much, Amy! You’re not too late… The new design is not even a week old yet. And I’m glad you’re with me on the cocktails. Let’s meet in the middle of the US and Australia and share some vino, eh? 🙂
Sounds like a great plan 🙂 Surely that midpoint must be a tropical island, right?
…I knew I liked you!
forgot to add to my last comment. I have original Pina Colada Cheesecake recipe that I got from the Dole Pineapple company more than 20 years ago. It is absolutely to die for. I also use pure Jamaican Rum. Its out of this world
Hello. I came across this delicious recipe and can’t wait to try it. My question is. Can this recipe be doubled for a 13×9 baking pan? Thanks in advance
Hey, LuAnn– yes! Enjoy.
I love, love, love coconut and I love pina coladas (and gettin’ caught in the rain). I can’t wait to try these, maybe with real rum instead of the extract? Lol 🙂
Haha! Yes! Please do and let me know how they turn out! Next time I make these, real rum it is! Thanks for stopping by, Trisha!
Those look and sound amazing! They look so cute with the cherries on top. 😉
My mom loved the cherries too! Thanks, Michele!
Hi Lynn
What brand of rum extract did you use in this recipe and where did you purchase it.
Hi, Jackie! I always purchase McCormick’s brand extracts, and I find them at my regular grocery store in the baking aisle next to the spices.
Hi, Lynn. Have you ever adapted this recipe for a 13×9 pan? I’m considering this recipe for a party. Thanks! 🙂
Hi, Michele! My best guess would be that if you did this recipe one and 1/2 times, it would fit in a 9×13 just fine. I’m afraid doubling it would be a bit too much, but if you try it, you’ll have to let me know!
I made these for a potluck this week, and one a half seemed like too much math, so I doubled the recipe and used an 11×15 pan. It worked perfectly and everyone loved them!
Thanks for letting me know, Hilary! Glad everyone enjoyed 🙂
Just made these for a dinner party. They look amazing! Can’t wait to taste 🙂
Super easy to make.
Thanks, Heather! How did you like them?
I would like to see how to make these i need the full recipe !
Hi Donna– the full recipe is above where you commented.
These are fantastic! I have Celaics so I substituted your delicious looking graham cracker crust for the almond crust found here: http://www.texanerin.com/mini-cheesecakes-grain-free-gluten-free/#_a5y_p=3864152
The end result was SO good! I will defiantly be coming back to this recipe. It was easy — and oh my goodness so good! Thank you for sharing.
So glad you enjoyed the bars! Thank you for letting me know!
I would like to know, can you use Pina Colada drink mix intead of the extracts?
Hi, Mary! If the flavor of the drink mix is strong enough, it should work ok. Let me know if you try it!
Since I do not care for graham crackers, do you think the shortbread crust you use in your lemon blueberry pie bars would work with this? I think it would be delicious.
Hmm, I think it could work, for sure! Let me know if you try it!
Made this for a dinner party I went to tonight. It was a big hit!! I opted for the coconut rum over the coconut and rum extracts and it turned out perfect with a few extra minutes of baking time. Everyone loved it (even my friend who’s not a big fan of coconut). Thanks for the recipe!
I love this report! Thanks so much, Ryan!
These were so delicious…I found this recipe while looking for a pineapple based cookie and I had to make it. Everyone at our house loved it.
Thanks so much!! 🙂
I have made these bars and they are very good. I am definitely going to make them again. The next time I am using a 9×9 pan.
Thanks so much, Patty!
Question? The recipe calls for full fat coconut milk but in your explanation you say put in sweetened condensed milk. Which one is it
Wow, Nancy– you caught me literally RIGHT in the middle of updating the post! HA! I originally used sweetened condensed milk but find a much better coconut flavor with coconut milk and granulated sugar as a replacement and just remade them this weekend (you can see them in a reel on Instagram from just a couple days ago). It’s all updated now and will be updated further later, but the recipe as is right now is fine to follow! Thanks 🙂
Does that mean usd all the original sugar and sweetened condensed milk
No. You do not need additional sugar with sweetened condensed milk. Use the recipe as written, please!
Clarification needed:
The NOTES section mentions rum extract and coconut extract if using rum or flavoured rum. Neither is included in the list of ingredients – only vanilla extract.
I would not be using rum at all so where do the rum and coconut extracts fit in and how much?
Thanks for catching that, Gary! Those were leftover from the original recipe I recently updated, and I forgot to change the notes section. Please see the updated notes if you’d like to use additional extracts.
Got it…thanks!
Can you clarify for me the baking time?
Hi, Darlene– it is 70-75 minutes. I hadn’t updated the top portion of the recipe card, but it’s updated now. Enjoy!
Hi, I have read this recipe several times as well as many other bar cookie recipes. I have never seen one that says to put the filling on the baked crust and bake for 70-75 minutes. That seems like a long time. I only bake my pound cakes that long. Most bar cookie recipes I have read with cream cheese on top call for baking for no more than about 30 minutes. I want to make these but I don”t want to over bake them. They sound delicious. I made a coconut custard pie once and used coconut milk and it was very good. Thanks for your help.
Hi, Mary– great question. The bake time is correct. The filling is VERY similar to a custard filling so will need ample time to set in the oven.
Thank you so much. I look forward to trying it.
Can these be refrigerated or frozen?
Those instructions are in the recipe 🙂